By Bob Garver

 

In the weeks leading up to “Ebenezer,” I couldn’t decide if I should be excited for the latest adaptation of Charles Dickens’ “A Christmas Carol.” I’ll express my prospective excitement by invoking another Dickens work, “A Tale of Two Cities”: It could be the best of films, it could be the worst of films. 

It could be the best of films because it comes from horror filmmaker Ti West. With a PG-13 rating simply for “frightening material,” West must have some scary tricks up his sleeve. I’m not above liking family-friendly adaptations of this work, but if this movie wants to go dark, it’s got the right person to make it dark. 

Then again, it could also be the worst of films because Johnny Depp plays Ebenezer Scrooge. Depp, who hasn’t given an acclaimed performance in years, is using his Jack Sparrow voice for the role, sending the message to anyone watching that advertising that he’s giving a complacent performance. 

The good news is that I was right about West’s horror touches. This is an adaptation where the Ghosts of Christmas Past and Present are so disturbing that Yet to Come, the one that is “supposed” to be scary, barely makes an impression. I’ll even deliver another piece of good news: Depp isn’t that bad. The Jack Sparrow-ness of the performance is distracting at first, but I got used to it quickly.

The bad news is that “Ebenezer” can’t escape the expectedness (not “Great” expectedness, just expectedness) of the source material. Sorry, but 116 minutes of often-familiar dialogue had me checking out. West and Depp almost pulled off this unsolicited collaboration, but not quite. 

 

Grade: C

 

“Ebenezer” is rated PG-13 for frightening material. Its running time is 116 minutes. 

 

Contact Bob Garver at rrg251@nyu.edu.